Mexico News Report

I recently reported on the July 4th protests in Mexico City. See In Mexico City, Gringo Immigrants are Targets of Mostly Peaceful Protest on July 4th.

The digital nomads moved to Mexico City from the U.S. Since they work online they can work anywhere. Combine that with already rising housing prices in Mexico City, plus the cultural and linguistic divide, and you have a problem.

A July 7th New York Times article discusses the topic and the political discussion of it.

From the New York Times: “In handwritten signs and graffiti, the protesters made their anger at the influx of foreigners who have recently settled in Mexico City clear: ‘Gringo, go home!’ ‘Speak Spanish or Die!’ ‘Gentrification is colonization!’ ”

Hey, when I lived in Mexico I spoke Spanish!

“In the protest, which took place on Friday [July 4], gathering spots for remote workers were ransacked. That drew a condemnation from Mexico’s president, Claudia Sheinbaum, on Monday morning [July 7].”

“But Ms. Sheinbaum also acknowledged the demonstrators’ concerns, and how tempers are flaring in Mexico City, North America’s largest metropolis, around the arrival of thousands of relatively well-off foreigners, especially from the United States. Many longtime residents are fuming over rising rents and food prices in parts of the city.”

Yes of course, residents don’t like rent and prices going up. The article quotes a resident.

“ ‘The playing field is not level,’ said Daniela Grave, a resident attending the protest. ‘If they make a living in dollars, and don’t pay taxes here, we are just in unequal circumstances, Mexicans and foreigners, where those who have salaries in dollars have all the power to exert in this city and that is what should be regulated.’ ”

“Tensions over the influx have been building for some time. Foreign remote workers began relocating in large numbers to Mexico City during the coronavirus pandemic, settling largely in central, pedestrian-friendly neighborhoods such as Condesa and Roma.”

“Jarring many longtime residents, these areas have developed into bastions where more English than Spanish is spoken in some sidewalk cafes, and in which co-working spaces, Pilates studios, specialty food stores and clothing boutiques have sprouted, catering to the recent arrivals.”

That’s happened in the U.S. on a much larger scale, with large neighborhoods where non-English languages are spoken.

Then there is the question of property values and rent:

“One of the main concerns that protesters are voicing has to do with surging rents and the value of real estate. Ms. Grave, 34, who has lived in the Roma Sur area for two decades, said she had watched her once quiet, family-oriented neighborhood undergo a slow but extreme transformation.”

That of course is a problem for residents.

“Corner grocery stores and affordable eateries have been replaced by upscale restaurants and curated art galleries. Even the local market where she buys produce has grown more expensive, often crowded with tourists and guides.”

“At neighborhood restaurants, she noted how waiters were now expected to speak English to serve foreign customers. The apartment buildings around her have turned into Airbnb hubs, some hosting late-night parties that, she says, have ‘changed the entire atmosphere of the neighborhood.’ ”

Digital nomads should learn Spanish.

“Ms. Grave, who joined the recent protest with her mother, emphasized that she didn’t have a problem with foreigners, and Americans in particular. But she expressed concern over the economic imbalances created when people with far greater purchasing power drive longtime residents out.”

“Other residents say that some of the privileged foreigners now living in Mexico City could take important steps to ease their neighbors’ concerns.”

“Luis Sosa, 44, a creative director who has lived in Condesa since 2006, said that Americans who move to Mexico could make more of an effort to understand the culture of the country. They could ‘be good neighbors, starting with learning Spanish,’ he said.”

“Mr. Sosa, who did not attend the protest, said he understood the frustration many residents felt, but rejected the violent, xenophobic tone of recent demonstrations, which he said echoed anti-migrant sentiment in parts of the United States.”

“Instead, he pointed to real-state developers capitalizing on rising demand and speculation, driving up rents, and to politicians who have failed to regulate the trend through public policy.”

“ ‘We are directing anger at the wrong places,’ he said. ‘What’s unacceptable is leaving it entirely to market forces while politicians look the other way.’ ”

“Mr. Sosa also warned against ‘nostalgia’ for what neighborhoods once were, saying that it could fuel resistance to potentially positive change.”

“ ‘Immigrants contribute economically and culturally,’ he said. ‘Neighborhoods and cities evolve and, like culture, they are changing all the time, they are not stagnant.’ ”

President Sheinbaum is trying to split the difference.

“Ms. Sheinbaum, a former mayor of Mexico City, said on Monday [July 7]that she disapproved of the protest while also criticizing the spread of gentrification in the city she used to govern.”

“ ‘No matter how legitimate a demand may be, such as opposing gentrification, it cannot call for any nationality to leave our country,’ she told reporters. ‘Mexico is a country open to the world.’ ”

“Ms. Sheinbaum also called attention to new real estate ventures that have led to rising property values and rents, driving up prices, displacing long-term residents and altering the character of neighborhoods.”

“ ‘There is already a lot of real estate speculation derived from Airbnb rentals and all these digital platforms,’ she said. ‘We cannot condone the rising cost of the city.’ ”

“In 2022, when she was the city’s mayor, Ms. Sheinbaum signed an agreement with Airbnb to promote Mexico City as the ‘capital of creative tourism’ — an effort to enhance the city’s reputation as a global hub for remote workers. At the time, Ms. Sheinbaum said she did not believe the company would increase prices for locals.”

Housing was getting more expensive for decades, even before the digital nomads.

“But the problem had started years, even decades, earlier.”

“A study published last year found that from 2000 to 2022 housing affordability in Mexico City plummeted as prices quadrupled and Mexicans’ incomes declined — with some gentrified neighborhoods experiencing an eightfold increase in housing prices.”

“The process has contributed to the emergence of clusters of highly expensive areas and the displacement of more than 23,000 low-income families each year.”

“ ‘Gentrification has been a constant,’ said Tamara Velasquez Leiferman, a Mexican urban studies expert at Rutgers University. ‘And what we’re seeing right now is the climax.’ ”

“Recent administrations have sought to tackle the issue, for example by subsidizing affordable housing and introducing some regulations to Airbnb — although officials have proposed lifting  restrictions to ensure the city can welcome the five million visitors expected to come for the 2026 FIFA World Cup.”

“Even before the protest targeting foreigners, some Mexico City residents had showed discomfort with the influx of wealthy transplants. In 2022, signs started appearing on the walls of buildings in Roma.”

“The signs asked: ‘New to the city? Working remotely?’ An obscenity-laden description of the newcomers as a ‘plague’ loathed by locals followed.”

“A new wave of xenophobic placards proliferated earlier this year on the streets of Condesa and Roma, blaming gentrification on foreigners, with a group called ‘Mexicans in Defense of the Nation’ taking credit.”

“ ‘Respect the locals and their culture, or leave,’ one of these signs read.  ‘Mexicans First.’ ”

Well, yes, it should be “Mexicans First” in Mexico.

“Arielle Simone, an American social media influencer, became the focus of ire after celebrating her move from Brooklyn in Mexico City in posts that drew hostile responses. Ms. Simone said that she had received threats that made it necessary to move to a new neighborhood.”

“But Ms. Simone, who did not respond to a request for comment, courted greater controversy when she started a GoFundMe campaign to raise $4,500 for that move. Some of her critics said that her appeal for such an amount underscored the disconnect between the living standards enjoyed by some Americans in the city and the challenges that many Mexicans face in making ends meet.”